Feature Articles: Environmental and Energy Technologies for ICT Society

Increasing the Lifetime and Reliability of Telecommunication Plant Materials

Yukitoshi Takeshita, Zhang Xiaoxi, Akira Sugiyama, and Takashi Sawada


We are researching and developing techniques to strengthen the reliability and environmental adaptation of telecommunication facilities in order to increase their lifetime. This article introduces examples of techniques to determine the degradation of coatings on telecommunication steel towers. An application to lightning damage prediction is also introduced as a risk-based facility maintenance strategy to evaluate the need for maintenance depending on the degree of risk.


1. Overview of telecommunication facilities

An enormous quantity of telecommunication plant materials is required to provide information and communications technology (ICT) services to communities. An example of some of the materials composing the outdoor infrastructure in the telecommunication field is shown in Fig. 1. NTT owns around 700,000 km of optical fiber cable, more than 1,100,000 km of long metal cable, approximately 12,000,000 telephone poles, and nearly 620,000 km of long cable conduits throughout Japan. Consequently, it is crucial to reduce the impact of these materials on the environment and to increase maintenance efficiency [1], [2]. We have investigated this issue focusing on the areas of materials science and a risk management system. In this article, we describe examples of techniques to determine the degradation of coatings on steel towers used for wireless telecommunications, and we introduce a risk-based facility maintenance application to predict lightning damage.

Fig. 1. Outdoor components of telecommunication equipment.

2. Technique to determine degradation of coatings

Steel towers and cable conduits under bridges are examples of outdoor equipment that are protected by organic coatings [3]. Steel towers have been installed at various NTT locations, and the maintenance of these huge structures includes periodical repainting.

2.1 Objective of degradation determination

Visual observation and adhesion testing are normally performed before NTT's steel towers are repainted. A practical cross-cut test (JIS K 5600-6-6) is used to evaluate adhesion. This involves cutting a section of the coating film into nine squares, placing adhesive tape over them, and then peeling off the tape. The number of remaining squares corresponds to the adhesion force. This is a simple evaluation method, although it is not very precise for detecting the onset of degradation. If the degradation goes undetected, corrosion will proceed, and this often results in the need to replace steel parts, which increases the maintenance cost. Therefore, we are developing new techniques to evaluate degradation.

2.2 Evaluation of film performance and material properties

We have introduced various coatings at NTT such as solvent-type coatings that are applied to steel towers and cable conduits used on bridges as well as powder coatings that are coated on steel telephone poles.

It is possible to efficiently determine the film degradation by clarifying the relationship between film performance, that is, the film's adhesive strength and impact resistance, and the material properties. We have focused on the material properties, which are measurable and useful for determining the appropriate time to repaint and replace components.

The relationship between the adhesive strength and crystallinity, one of the material properties [4], is shown in Fig. 2 for powder coatings. The crystallinity is the ratio of crystalline parts in a crystalline and non-crystalline mixture of polymer material. Polyester powder is a crystalline polymer, so the film performance varies depending on the degree of crystallinity. Good performance, which is higher adhesive strength here, was obtained with up to 3% crystallinity, as shown in Fig. 2.

Fig. 2. Relationship between adhesive strength and crystallinity.

The relationship between the impact resistance and crystallinity [4] is shown in Fig. 3. As with adhesive strength, it is observed that higher impact resistance is obtained in the lower crystallinity region.

Fig. 3. Relationship between impact resistance and crystallinity.

We were able to clarify practical film performance by understanding one of the basic material properties (crystallinity in this case).

2.3 Study of new material indicator

We are developing new criteria to determine coating degradation and are focusing on viscoelasticity to quantify the degree of degradation of solvent-type anti-corrosion organic coating films. Viscoelasticity, as the name suggests, is the combination of viscous and elastic properties. It is generally known that most of the energy necessary to peel a film is consumed by deformation of the bulk material, and thus, the adhesive performance strongly depends on the viscoelasticity. Also, we previously reported that the viscoelasticity of solvent-type anticorrosion organic coating film varies depending on the degradation [5]. Thus, we believe that it is possible to precisely evaluate the degree of degradation by measuring viscoelasticity as the material property of the coating film. Furthermore, because this measurement is very sensitive to even a small variation of the property and because the measurement distribution is small, this technique is expected to indicate the onset of degradation.

3. Risk-based maintenance

Risk-based maintenance is a new methodology for maintaining infrastructure that involves assessing the risk for each component of the infrastructure and preparing an appropriate maintenance plan for each component on the basis of the risk assessment. This method makes it possible to balance the need to control maintenance costs with the requirement to ensure the reliability of the infrastructure. This method was developed with the intended use of maintaining chemical plants in western countries and is also being applied in chemical plants in Japan [6]. Telecommunication industries have not yet applied this method. The risk for a component is determined by the expected likelihood and consequences of a specific failure of the component. One of the first research tasks is to establish a method of estimating the likelihood and consequences using some particular data, such as information on facility features, inspection results, and weather information. Here, we introduce a method of estimating the risk of lightning damage.

3.1 Aim of method to evaluate risk of lightning damage

For many years, damage to telecommunication infrastructure caused by lightning surges has been a serious issue [7]. The cost associated with such damage has been increasing year on year as low-voltage LSIs (large-scale integrated circuits) and electrical devices connected to the network become more prevalent in the ever-expanding information technology (IT) society. Furthermore, our study of long-term trends in the number of annual days with lightning [8] indicates that lightning damage will become more serious because of the increased occurrence of lightning in Japan in conjunction with future global warming.

Although lightning damage can be reduced by introducing lightning protection countermeasures, it is difficult to introduce countermeasures uniformly throughout the country because of the high cost. An advanced method is needed to classify areas by the cost-effectiveness of introducing countermeasures. We have been researching a method to evaluate the risk of lightning damage; it involves estimating the potential number of equipment failures and the subsequent economic loss. The estimation of the potential number of equipment failures corresponds to likelihood estimation in the risk-based maintenance, and the economic loss estimation corresponds to the consequence estimation.

3.2 Model for estimating degree of lightning damage

We analyzed the relationship between the number of equipment failures, the number of lightning strikes, i.e., the cause of the damage, and the amount of equipment, i.e., the location of the damage. A scatter plot graph of the logarithmic values of these three variables, where the resident population is substituted for the amount of equipment, is shown in Fig. 4. As this graph indicates, the number of equipment failures is proportional to both the number of lightning strikes and the resident population. Thus, we defined the lightning damage estimation model [9] as:

1og(Y)=log(a)+ b11og(L)+b21og(P).

Here, Y is the number of equipment failures; L is the number of lightning strikes; P is the resident population; and a, b1, and b2 are coefficients of regression. We conducted a case study of three prefectures in Japan to validate the accuracy of the model using past data, and we confirmed that the correlation coefficient between the values estimated using our estimation model and the actual values was more than 0.8. These correlations can be considered statistically significant.

Fig. 4. Relationship between number of lightning strikes, lightning damage, and population.

3.3 Prediction of future lightning damage and equipment failures

The potential number of equipment failures can be estimated using the estimation model from the predicted number of lightning strikes [8] and population in the future. The average numbers of lightning strikes and equipment failures between 2006 and 2010 in Gunma prefecture, where the density of lightning strikes is among the highest in Japan, are shown in Fig. 5. The average predicted numbers of lightning strikes and equipment failures between 2026 and 2030 are shown in Fig. 6. The predicted results show that the number of equipment failures in the late 2020s will increase owing to the remarkable increase in the number of subscribers of optical fiber broad- band services and the increase in the number of lightning strikes.

Fig. 5. Annual average measured number of lightning strikes and actual number of cases of lightning damage from 2006 to 2010.

Fig. 6. Annual average predicted number of lightning strikes and predicted number of cases of lightning damage from 2026 to 2030.

3.4 Identification of high-priority areas for countermeasures

We are using the results of our study to analyze the potential economic loss and the cost-benefit of implementing lightning countermeasures in nearly every region of Japan. Our method makes it possible to identify the areas where countermeasures should be implemented first and is thus expected to be useful to ensure the reliability of telecommunications services and to optimize maintenance costs by reducing lightning damage and maintenance work.

4. Future prospects

NTT will continue to develop techniques to assess degradation by focusing on coating properties and risk-based maintenance and will also continue working to reduce both environmental load and maintenance costs in the future.


[1] T. Sawada, Y. Takeshita, H. Saito, Y. Higashi, S. Sakata, and T. Handa, "Recent Strides to Make Telecommunications Plant More Environmentally Friendly and Reliable," NTT Technical Review, Vol. 7, No. 10, 2009.
[2] T. Sawada, H. Saito, Y. Higashi, and H. Sakaino, "Anti-corrosion Technologies for Telecommunications Structures and Equipment," NTT Technical Review, Vol. 9, No. 2, 2011.
[3] "Coatings for Protecting Telecommunication Steel Towers," NTT Technical Review, Vol. 8, No. 12, 2010.
[4] Y. Takeshita, T. Sawada, T. Handa, and T. Kudo, "The Effect of Cooling Time on Properties of Thermoplastic Powder Coating Films for Telecommunication Plants," Proc. of NACE CORROSION 2011, Paper No. 11374, Houston, Texas, USA, 2011.
[5] T. Kamisho, Y. Takeshita, S. Sakata, and T. Sawada, "Study on Evaluation of Film Performance for Anti-corrosion Coating Used in Telecommunication Plant by Dynamic Viscoelastic Measurement," Bosei-Kanri, Vol. 55, No. 12, pp. 449454, 2011 (in Japanese).
[6] High Pressure Institute of Japan, "Risk Based Maintenance Handbook Part 1 General," HPIS Z 107-1TR:2010, 2010 (in Japanese).
[7] T. Tominaga, N. Aoki, and H. Yamane, "Comparison of Lightning Malfunction Prediction Methods Using Lightning Strike Density and Subscriber Line Density," Proc. of the IEICE General Conference 2003, Vol. 1, p. 449, 2003 (in Japanese).
[8] A. Sugiyama, X. Zhang, R. Uchida, T. Sawada, H. Miura, and M. Kimoto, "Analysis of Long-term Trends in the Number of Thunder Days Using the Simulation Results of Global Warming (2)," Proc. of the 2011 Autumn Meeting of the Meteorological Society of Japan, Vol. 100, p. 464, 2011 (in Japanese).
[9] X. Zhang, A. Sugiyama, and H. Kitabayashi, "Estimating Telecommunication Equipment Failures due to Lightning Surges by Using Population Density," Proc. of the 2011 IEEE International Conference on Quality and Reliability, pp. 182185, Bangkok, Thailand, 2011.
Yukitoshi Takeshita
Senior Research Scientist, NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories.
He received the B.E., M.E., and Ph.D. degrees in applied chemistry from Kyushu University, Fukuoka, in 1987, 1989, and 2001, respectively. Since joining NTT in 1989, he has been engaged in R&D of conductive dual-phase polymer for mobile phones, supercritical fluid technology for environmental remediation, and materials science for high reliability of telecommunication plants. He has also been involved in environmental promotion activities for NTT and has been a Center of Environmental Auditors Registration (CEAR) Environmental Lead Auditor for ISO 14001. His recent research interest is polymer materials for eco-friendly coatings. He became an Adjunct Lecturer at Kyushu University in 2012. He received the NTT President's Award in 2009 and was featured in a Nikkei Business Newspaper article on Talented People in Japan IT in 2010.
Xiaoxi Zhang
Research Engineer, Green Material Project, NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories.
She received the B.S. and M.S. degrees in social engineering from Tokyo Institute of Technology in 2007 and 2009, respectively. She joined NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories in 2009. She is currently researching methods of risk-based management of telecommunication infrastructures. She is a member of the Institute of Electronics, Information and Communication Engineers.
Akira Sugiyama
Senior Research Engineer, Green Material Project, NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories.
He received the B.S. and M.S. degrees in computer science from Tokyo Institute of Technology in 1994 and 1996, respectively. He joined NTT Basic Research Laboratories in 1996 and engaged in research on natural language processing. He moved to NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories in 2004. He is currently researching methods of risk-based management of telecommunication infrastructures. He is a member of the Information Processing Society of Japan.
Takashi Sawada
Senior Research Engineer, Group Leader, NTT Energy and Environment Systems Laboratories.
He received the B.E. and M.E. degrees in electronics science from Nihon University, Tokyo, in 1989 and 1991, respectively. Since joining NTT in 1992, he has been engaged in R&D of polymer optical devices and in promoting environmental management in the NTT Group. He is currently working on making telecommunication plant materials and maintenance technologies more environmentally friendly and reliable.